Thursday, January 12, 2006

GETTING TRADED INCLUDES EMOTIONAL BAGGAGE, TOO

Earlier this week, Herman Edwards was traded from the New York Jets to the Kansas City Chiefs as the new head coach, replacing Dick Vermeil who retired after five seasons. During his introductory news conference, Edwards was very complimentary about his former career with the Jets.

"I owe a debt of gratitude to [owner] Woody Johnson. He gave a young coach a chance to be a head coach when maybe a lot of people wouldn't do that. I thank him for that, and I thank the organization for that. And I thank my players my last five years in New York for making me a better man. I hope I made a difference, and I hope I make a difference here."

But Edwards refused to discuss why he departed The Big Apple.

"What happened in New York stays in New York. So if you ask any questions about what happened, I'll tell you right now, it stays in the family."

Solely through the announcement and coverage of the trade, the public knew Edwards was exchanged for a future fourth-round draft pick. But Edwards' private manner led the public to believe that he wanted to catch a one-way flight out west because he was frustrated coaching the Jets. He endured a 39-41 five-year record (4-12 this season) and recurring injuries to his two star players - quarterback Chad Pennington and running back Curtis Martin. On the flip side, Edwards' new team, the Chiefs, are an organization on the rise (finished 10-6), thanks in large part to a breakout season by halfback Larry Johnson who was third in the league in rushing with 1,750 yards.

Although Edwards gave praise to his previous owner and players, his secretive point-of-view symbolizes the lack of information the public knows about the trials and tribulations of trades in professional sports. It's more than the reactions from players and coaches on representing a new logo. Those quotes can be easily accessed through a press conference recap.


There just isn't enough behind-the-scenes reporting on this significant type of sports business transaction. How do players and coaches prepare to move? How do they adjust to living in a new city? What is the process like of fitting in with a new team? How are their families and friends affected by the whole ordeal?

Furthermore, there should be detailed issues raised on trading technicalities. How are trade talks initiated and finalized between teams? Besides player value, what other factors contribute to a deal? What are the hot topics and future trends in the trading business?

It's important to realize that players and coaches may be multi-millionaires, but it's the team's management - with some making less money incidentally - which can treat them like indentured slaves. They can feel cheated and abused suddenly and constantly, so getting traded includes emotional baggage, too. Some players, such as Eddie Jones of the Memphis Grizzlies, have received word they were traded while on vacation. Others, such as Jim Jackson of the Phoenix Suns, have suited up for more than 10 teams.


As Edwards demonstrated by his restrained comments, some players and coaches may remain hush-hush when they're traded because it can be a difficult and irritating transition. It's one of the ultimate cold sores in professional sports because deals are sometimes unpredicted and completed behind closed doors, so it can be a touchy subject. But it's worth investigating further.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

The concept of trading people is barbaric. It is still going on today with people being bought and sold. Sports figures are programmed to keep emotions in check and the public has no reason to feel the pain they don't see. Fans also think that money makes everything feel better.

Anonymous said...

Jerry Maguire, Mr. Baseball, etc... all follow that idea of humanizing (yet still celebrating) the sports dream. I would imagine its the same with movie stars.

I can't argue with the comment that money makes you feel better. But it does give you the opportunity to peace out whenever you want (aka "fuck you" money).

i'd be interested in hearing more trade horror stories.

Anonymous said...

youz da man g funk craig

Anonymous said...

keep my name out your mouth.

Anonymous said...

There are comments that go further into looking at the subject and others that lead nowhere.

Anonymous said...

The part of this discussion and the original posting that intrigues me the most is, how does the subject of trading players get opened up in the first place? is it two GMs on a golf course and one guy saying, "You know who I really like on your roster ..." Or is there a formal protocol observed? or are there back channel feelers sent out by third parties? I feel that I know a fair amount about sports but this is one area I'm completely in the dark about. I'd guess that for every 10 trades there are 10 different methods for going about it, but that initial contact between teams — which I'm sure must be surrounded in Manhattan Project levels of secrecy — is fascinating.

Jared and Alex said...

Overall, it would be easier to follow around an athlete who has just been traded than to follow around a team's general manager to see how he finalizes a trade. Access is key and players definitely open up more on camera. On the other hand, team management would probably provide information if they were allowed to remain anonymous. Whatever the case, a documentary or short series idea needs to be pitched!